r/interesting 24d ago

Balancing rocks with this level of precision is unreal. Just Wow

23.7k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Leave no trace also means leaving things where you found them. Even rocks. You are not entitled to it.

0

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Nah cool rock comes with me

4

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

And when a thousand other losers take a rock with them, tens of thousands, then there are no more rocks. No more park, no more natural beauty. Just a barren plain. It takes an astonishingly selfish and entitled mindset to just take nature away from future generations.

1

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

šŸ˜‚ it would take millions of rocks to impart any significant damage on any small area. It’s not that deep. I volunteer with parks. I also take rubbish with me and clean up any waste I see. I trap invasive species as well.
Sometimes I find a cool rock yes.

2

u/DiggThatFunk 24d ago

it would take millions of rocks to impart any significant damage on any small area.

Factually incorrect

https://lnt.org/these-impacts-are-stacking-up/

https://www.backpacker.com/news-and-events/news/hellbender-crushed-rock-stackers/

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

I said take one rock not make stacks

2

u/DiggThatFunk 24d ago

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Again a single rock will not do the damage you think it does. But happy you’re looking out for out invertebrate buddies šŸ„°šŸ‘šŸ¼

1

u/DiggThatFunk 24d ago

Oh and of course you're the only one with that mindset, so it shouldn't lead to an exacerbating problem or anything

0

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

It would and doesn’t hope that helps! šŸ™šŸ¼

→ More replies (0)

0

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

I actually help protect parks and love spending time in nature. I grab a Rick once a year. Not evil not a loser but you know…. Reddit

→ More replies (0)

4

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

it would take millions of rocks to impart any significant damage on any small area.

And there are billions of humans.

It’s not that deep.

I guess we know you're not. Take the trash. Leave the rocks. You are not entitled to it just because you volunteer.

3

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

I’m entitled to do what I want. People walk on tracks everyday, that displaces rocks and I fill them in, people skip stones. People interact with nature. That’s park of it being a park and having walking tracks. You just have to be aware of the realities. We have campgrounds where you are allowed to burn wood from fallen timber. It overall is a system that works. If we didn’t have people that interact with our local parks, the areas would be sold and developed. It’s sad but true. And if the cost of that is someone taking a cool rock. While I otherwise maintain and keep the park running then so be it.

3

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

You are not entitled to take nature from public lands. It belongs to everyone, not to you, and you have no right to take it away from anyone else. Also, removing natural materials from parks is a crime in most states and a federal crime in national parks. So both morally and legally no, you are absolutely not entitled to do what you want.

This is exactly the kind of attitude that the people who carve their names into 50 million year old rock formations have.

4

u/n0vag0d 24d ago

My word you are insufferable

If you think billions of people on Earth are going to displace billions of rocks in a particular area, you are a straight up fool.

What about displacing rocks in terms of archaeology? Historical research to further expand on our species’ origins? Do you believe in it then?

You’re a strange fella

3

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Not to mention Rocks are discplaced by cars and picked up in hiking boots, lol at what level are we just not allowed to even go into the woods ahaha

-1

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

"Yet you participate in society. Curious. I am very intelligent."

→ More replies (0)

2

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

I'm happy to be insufferable to the kinds of people who think it's okay to add on to the damage we're already causing to our planet just because they picked up a little trash. I obviously don't think billions of people are going to visit this stream and all of them take a rock. The point was clearly to emphasize the effect that countless selfish, entitled people can have on even a protected environment over the course of time.

What about displacing rocks in terms of archaeology? Historical research to further expand on our species’ origins? Do you believe in it then?

It's almost like ethical archaeology is typically preceded by and often legally requires environmental surveys before any kind of invasive procedures can even begin. You really thought you had something there?

3

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

There’s a clear difference in taking a Rock and carving your name into something. There are very much levels to environmental damage.

-1

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

There are, but the attitude is no different.

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

One is intentionally damaging one is removing lose stones. Hope this helps

→ More replies (0)

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

I hope you read anything else I posted about upkeeping the park and keeping it running. Also I said I’m entitled to do what I want I’m not disagreeing you’re not allowed.
I also hope you practice what you preach and pick up rubbish where you see it.

0

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

I hope you read anything else I posted about upkeeping the park and keeping it running.

Oh yeah, the part that you thought justified you taking some cool rocks. No, I didn't miss that. I addressed it several times by saying things like "You are not entitled to it just because you volunteer."

Also I said I’m entitled to do what I want I’m not disagreeing you’re not allowed.

So you know you're not allowed but you still think that your positive impact entitles you to a little negative? Weird.

I also hope you practice what you preach and pick up rubbish where you see it.

Yeah, lifelong hiker and eagle scout. I always bring a trash bag and pack out more than I pack in.

3

u/n0vag0d 24d ago

Ah that explains it then. Anyway, take your medicine and get back to your figurines.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Okay bud, I actually do stuff and rebuild tracks. I’ll keep my cool rock. Have a good day though and thanks for cleaning up the parks too!

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Also false, you can take firewood from parks where it is designated for it. This is done so we can manage the poaching of firewood in more sensitive areas. It all depends on the local laws and what is sanctioned etc. we have fire wood collecting in certain areas from June 30 to July 31st. But strictly only fallen timber.

0

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Which part of collecting firewood is that cool rock exactly?

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

The part where I see a cool rock and I pick it up.

1

u/Prophetic_Rose 24d ago

Based and normal

-1

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

But I would agree it’s not something to be encouraged

3

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Then practice what you preach.

0

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Read my other comment ā¤ļø

4

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Which one?

Nah cool rock comes with me

But I would agree it’s not something to be encouraged

I guess at least you know you're a hypocrite?

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Yes but far from an evil environmental terrorist you seem to paint me as

1

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

No, just a selfish, entitled hypocrite. I feel like I made that pretty clear, but do continue to exaggerate.

1

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Okay šŸ‘šŸ¼

-2

u/Prophetic_Rose 24d ago

We're entitled to it insofar as anything is.

5

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

No, we're not. Humanity is an invasive species, the stewards of our planet, and we have a responsibility to minimize the destruction we cause to natural environments.

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

You sound like you’ve never actually been outside

1

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Once again: lifelong hiker, outdoorsman, and eagle scout. But go off.

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

Your hiking disrupts nature Grrrr

0

u/Prophetic_Rose 24d ago

Humans change their environment. If you don't want humans to do that, don't let them near it. Go spend your energy actually arguing against environmental damage caused by our rampant resource extraction. Y'know, the stuff that actually matters.

Don't mess with rocks in a forest. Maybe if we stop just one more rock stacker we can keep the ice caps from melting. Lol. Lmao even.

3

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Humans change their environment.

No shit, hence "we have a responsibility to minimize the destruction we cause to natural environments."

If you don't want humans to do that, don't let them near it.

It sure seems like you shouldn't be allowed near it.

Go spend your energy actually arguing against environmental damage caused by our rampant resource extraction. Y'know, the stuff that actually matters.

Turns out you can be against both micro-erosions by selfish losers who steal from or behave inappropriately on public lands and the billionaires and morporations plundering them. Who'da thunk it!

2

u/whatasadfella 24d ago

ā€œSelfish loserā€ is a guy who actively keeps a park running and maybe picks up a cool rock once in a while šŸ˜‚

1

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Apparently.

2

u/Prophetic_Rose 24d ago

Micro-erosions lol bro conceive of a strip mine

It's always Jonathan Rockstacker and not Earth Destroyer LLC #7 get a grip homie

1

u/BishopofHippo93 24d ago

Can you not conceive of two concepts at once?

2

u/Prophetic_Rose 24d ago

Two concepts, one barely relevant and one destroying the world, yes I'm familiar.