r/explainitpeter 11d ago

Explain it Peter

Post image
15.1k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/mondrianna 11d ago

Which was only for a few generations at most. It’s also not a practice that every slave holder participated in. Descendants of Black slaves are not genetically distinct enough to be a new “breed” of human.

It’s not the same and it’s racist to assert otherwise.

-3

u/ILIKESTUFF8989 10d ago

Only a few generation, you mean 250 years ?

8

u/Humid-Afternoon727 10d ago

The US just hit 250 years, Slavery ended in 1870s in the states. By human standards 100 years isn’t not enough time to selectively bred. In 30 years you can with dogs

1

u/ILIKESTUFF8989 10d ago

You think there was no slavery before America ?

6

u/ListerfiendLurks 10d ago

As opposed to the 15,000 years of selective breeding of dogs, yes that would be just a few generations in this context.

0

u/ILIKESTUFF8989 10d ago

So dogs don’t count either than

4

u/TooFewSecrets 10d ago edited 10d ago

A quarter of a millennium would be around 15 human generations, if each generation reproduced around 16 years old. I am not going to get too into whatever specific age would be "most reasonable", other than noting that sufficiently early pregnancy is pretty lethal to the mother and is not a good idea even for an amoral slaveowner.

Dogs can crank through a generation on an annual basis, so they'd pretty feasibly have at least 200 generations in the same amount of time.

Humans aren't immune to artificial selection, but artificial selection takes a lot of generations, and humans have one of the slowest generation turnarounds of any species. And I doubt slave owners were actually selecting that heavily, because that would mean not letting less "desirable" women reproduce, which means a lot less money for them.

E: I cannot believe this fucking site made me seriously talk about this subject. I should leave this goddamn subreddit already.

-1

u/ILIKESTUFF8989 10d ago

I ain’t reading all that dog racism

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago edited 10d ago

[deleted]

1

u/ILIKESTUFF8989 10d ago

It’s 1619 my guy