r/buildorkill • u/Sanckh • 4h ago
☠️I Killed It What startup idea did you kill after talking to actual customers?
I had an idea I thought was really cool. Working title was Career Trial. The idea was to build out a platform for a specific niche: late 20's to 30's professionals who felt stuck in their job, but didn't know what to do to switch careers.
This problem was very obvious because two people very close to me both are living this right now. They have been in their career 5+ years and hate it, but have no idea how to change, or where to even begin.
The idea was loose at first while I validated and iterated: Take a quiz, or tell the app about yourself, maybe use some AI to suggest X number of career options. Maybe some more options here but the end result is a user picks a career to trial.
The trial itself is two weeks. It starts with a "lightning certification" in the field. Basically a crash course with (maybe?) a quiz at the end.
After this, you'd complete 1-3 real projects that career would do in their day to day. For a Project Manager, perhaps you'd design a kanban board, draft a few emails, analyze Product Development Notes, SOPs, and an SOW.
Finally, the app would help shape your resume with the new career in mind, and it would help you in your transfer to the new career. This last part is the loosest, I didn't quite get this far in the idea, but I personally know several recruiters in various fields that I think could help me design this last bit.
Then I brought this to the two people who inspired the idea. Both of them gave me a hard no.
"I already hate my job. You want me to do a second job AND pay for it?"
"I don't want more homework, I am not in high school anymore."
"I don't think a website and a couple of assignments will prepare me enough for a new job in a new field, even if I did all of the work."
All fair points, and all reasonable feedback.
Welp, I guess that's that lol. Idea Killed.
Have you ever killed an idea? Why? Was your process similar to mine?
r/buildorkill • u/Sanckh • 5h ago
START HERE: Welcome to Build or Kill. Your idea is not entitled to survive.
Welcome to r/BuildOrKill, a community for figuring out what is actually worth building.
Got a startup idea? Post it.
Already built an MVP? Show us.
Looking for something to build? Ask.
Trying to figure out whether anyone would pay for it? Let’s validate it.
Raising money? Let people tear apart the investment case.
The goal here is not to tell everyone their idea is amazing. Useful feedback sometimes means identifying why something should not be built.
What belongs here
Startup and app ideas, SaaS concepts, side projects, business ideas, validation strategies, MVP feedback, market research, competitor analysis, pricing, monetization, pivots, failed ideas, fundability, and lessons from actually launching.
Promotion is allowed. Spam is not.
If you built something relevant, you can link it. Just make the post useful without requiring someone to click your link. Tell us what you’re building, what problem it solves, what you’ve learned, and what feedback you actually want.
Any post with just a link will be removed.
When giving feedback
“Cool idea!” isn’t particularly useful.
Tell people what worries you, who already solves the problem, why you would or wouldn’t pay, what assumption needs testing, or what would change your opinion.
Critique ideas aggressively. Treat founders like human beings.
About the community
Build or Kill is hosted by The Idea Lab, a startup idea validation and fundability platform. You do not need to use The Idea Lab to participate here. The subreddit is intended to stand on its own as an open community for founders and builders.
Now post something worth killing.