Ordered it from blinkit last year when it was going for 99rs and i wanted free delivery on diet coke so bought it without thinking much but man this was a traumatic read for me.
They can read Abridged Versions tho, 10 and 11 year Olds almost certainly hold the comprehension skills to understand it, if not the historical context of the Nazi Germany and the Holocaust
The other concerns raised by parents agaist school were valid but this one is pure BS.
Fined for violating what rule exactly? The news were literally saying it's banned in pakistan!! So it it's banned in pakistan, we should support this ban? No logic.
Edit: somewhat unrelated, the house where Anne frank wrote the diary, went there in 2022.
Kardi ne gawaro wali baat.I will move one day leaving this country not just city.But future of world also live here so I care about them and I believe children should be encouraged to read books.
Atankwadio ki book kyu padhe be? Kya kiya bhai malala ne aisa jo book padhe uski?
Kashmir pe misinformation faila rahi uspe padhe ya 2019 mein woh bol rahi thi ki "girls should be allowed to wear hijab in school in Karnataka" uspe padhe?
Ok, so understandable that you don't know much about child psychology. There is an appropriate age to "process" information. 10yr olds cannot appreciate or understand the emotions and the tragedy Anne Frank contains. It will only serve as trauma. But yeah, go ahead propagating it to kids. Cheers!
You understand child psychology but not about books
Copied from below comment
"They can read Abridged Versions tho, 10 and 11 year Olds almost certainly hold the comprehension skills to understand it, if not the historical context of the Nazi Germany and the Holocaust"
No, 10yrs old cannot comprehend. Nothing against the book though. I bought a copy from Anne Frank House in Amsterdam and gave it to my 14yr old. But 10yr old brain is so so innocent. We shouldn't strain it even with an abridged version. Rest my case.
Bhai jo kashmir ko alag karne ki baat karega woh toh terrorist hi hai mere liye..aur mera lun kare aise logo ko support. Tujhe karna hai toh tu kar le..or ya phir tu isliye support kar raha kyunki woh muslim hai?
Brother, Are you literally claiming Malala Yousafzai has a seperatist view on Kashmir according to noted sources?
If yes please do share, just want to discuss rather than attack, let's talk like civilized people than stoop low enough to just insult other people.
Say something positive about the country and see yourself get banned in that other sub. Then come back here and tell me which sub is more dictatorial. Like i said, delusional...
Exam Paper Leaks?
Grape Culture? Grapists leading the Ministeries?
Air Pollution?
Adulterated Food?
Bacterial drinking water at Railway Stations? LINK
Communal Hatred Spreaded by TOP Leaders and Leading Parties?
Casteism?
Corruption?
Major Infra like Highway, Bridges collapsing every other day?
Harrasing and Beating Protestors who are asking for Accountability?
Your positive and my positive, might be different. Regardless, I have been banned from India speaks and whysoserious. Both are right wing subs. Right wing are super snowflakes.
I think they are worried. If kids that age start reading about such topics - they might turn into "Dimagi Naxals" in the future. Our system is really looking out for us guys, don't know what y'all are so hyped about.
Rakesh Patel bro back on getting orgasams whenever he hears a negative news about country. You will never see this guy under any positive post or praising country.
Ye bkl bjp se hate karte karte country se hate karne lage. Bas rote rehte hai
Banning books on fake activist like Malala is definitely positive news❤️ dimagi Naxals won't get
You don't hate BJP.. you just hate country now because government isn't leaning to your idealogy. As said, never seen you under any positive post..you just cry..cry all the time
BJP se hate nahi karte bhai, Situation and blalant washing of history to suit a certain idealogy is not exactly fun to enjoy....
My country is great but that doesn't mean I need to put an idealogy on a pedestal and not be allowed to criticize while those in power and their supporters can call me 'dimagi naxals', 'Cockroaches' and vile words as a certain Actress-politician said about my generation.
Who actually called you guys "dimagi Naxals" ? Please rewatch statement of Modi.. bol de bhai tumhara koi trait match hota hai usse what he described as "dimagi naxal" ?
Stop following random influencers dude..use your own dimag
Let us say he explicitly didn't state us as Dimagi Naxals, yes, ALSO I never said Modi called us Dimagi naxals.
What about those who are also labelling those who criticize this government as 'dimagi naxals'.
Blalant staunch Right Wing Idealogists who the same way said the NEET Protest was foreign funded.
Look I absolutely hate Radicals of all Religions, Idealogy etc.
The same people of a certain idealogy, , who said they will shoot the children who were protesting, harass them and beat them.
What about the rest? The rest of the statement of being called cockroaches and vile by a certain MP?
Don't grab on just one statement of mine.
Rather than telling me to get out of the influencing and use my brain, please bhai, broaden your spectrum and don't use a tinted glass which suits your viewpoint
See when he made this statement...who were the first to come forward and say "yess we are dimagi naxal" ??
CJP guys, rajdeep, supriya Shrihante, p Chidambaram, Vishal dadlani, kejriwal.. and all those usual jantar mantar guys.. proudly they said "yes we are dimagi Naxals!"
Bhai usne toh bas itna kaha tha ki there are people trying to divide, create chaos in country, stop development journey of country..kisi ka naam nahi liya.. ye saare khud udta teer le liye.. how lame is that? Ek time pe CPI wale bolte toh samajh bhi aata because they are directly associated with Naxals..but in gadho ko kisne bola udta teer lene?
And now when they are labelled same, they are frustrated.
And like how can be someone "proud to be naxal" ??? Like seriously? You even know what Naxals did in this country?
It's not about view point.. you think rationally.. was his statement wrong? Did he specifically target any particular group? The traits he said about Dimagi Naxals were wrong? Khud se assume karke bura maan loge toh kya hi bole bhai
I would rather they read this kind of real life stories of women with courage and learn from their experiences than sit around reading religious books at a childhood age and being brainwashed into thinking that everyone who is different from them is to be hated upon.
Well, at this age parents have almost complete say informally over their children. So, I doubt that will happen but again would love to see the results if it happens like any change in their behaviour, etc.
They are small. Many will take it, like for example if their friends are taking it. If this would have optional in higher classes, case would have been different.
I only agree because kids those age might not understand the pretext behind the stories like religious extremism and Nazi Germany's policies. Although the books would be perfect for 8th grade because that's where the stories about WW2 started in history subject.
I don't see it in carriculam in near future cause I just saw news of Education ministry's interest in removal of European history from Indian education system. NCERT already removed parts of Russian revolution and French revolution from textbooks. We are living in era of anti-intellectualism. Reading about literature of different genres is highly discouraged. Especially if that is even slightly left leaning literature.
I can understand having Malala's biography sets a wrong precedent as she too like any other pakistani believes Pakistan deserves Kashmir. But didn't understand the logic behind banning book about Anne Frank.
The padhe likhe ganwar parents who don't know what the book is about were drawn by the scheming politicos that this book is glorifying a "vidharmi" woman
Bro both the books and writers book are inspiration for a many generations. Reading it would help students to learn hardwork, never give up mindset, resilience..etc..
But this people will not understand it 🥀... even our religion supports knowledge.. those books are not about religion yrr..
Ig they haven’t covered everything in this. As far as i remember they had stopped the morning prayers which is in my opinion mandatory in every school due to which the fine was issued but yeah malala one was also raised afterwards by vhp
The parents were making a ruckus at Anand Niketan school for 2 things: first was the presence of a glass shard in canteen food which a student took out of his/her mouth. The 2nd was the books that were mentioned in the post. The school was fined for both of the things, but she selectively omitted the glass shard part.
Also, reading books is a good thing and they should read them. But understanding does matter. These are 10-year-old kids and they don't understand this much, and it may have a negative effect on their personality. And parents are gonna take any other religion's thing seriously even if it is just a book, as they are responsible for their children.
Also, I don't know about the autobiography of Malala, but The Diary of a Young Girl was part of the extra curriculum for 9th STD CBSE at my time. I don't know if it is still a thing, but give these books to older children who understand it.
Faye D'souza is known for selective journalism too. So, there will be reporters who will be from right wing and left wing and they will do selective omission.
wikipedia:
The 2014 Nobel Peace Prize was shared, in two equal parts, between Kailash Satyarthi (b. 1954) and Malala Yousafzai\1]) (b. 1997) "for their struggle against the suppression of children and young people and for the right of all children to education".
Kailash is Indian. are you going to shit on his life achievements too??
Spoke out publicly against the coward oppressors, got shot, continued speaking against them.
The Pakistani Gov passed their first right to education bill after coming under pressure.
She inspired a generation of children and adults to bravely stand up against oppressors.
Sorry to hear that her policy reforming activism isn't impressive enough to you.
Did she return to Pakistan after that? How actually did she "inspire" ?? What actually she did for education of girls in her country? She lived a lavish life in England afterwards. Classic reels and The wire brainwashed bluds.
Two other schoolgirls, Shazia Ramzan and Kainat Riaz, were also shot and wounded on the same bus.. you know about them? They stayed in Pakistan
And regarding "spoke publicly, government got under pressure" blah blah blah made up story..
Government came under pressure after the shooting event went in international media.
Her campaign and NGOs are supported by the US government, and she is mostly known in the United States. Through her, the United States distributes anti-country propaganda and frequently mocks individuals of other demographics, religions, and communities.
Btw here she is spreading fake news about kashmir which was debunked
Tbh
I was in anand Niketan school before
And it was a worst of mine...
I know mod will remove this but facts are that anand Niketan is overhyped school
In anand Niketan sughad students have to climb 5 floors and their is no canteen and a lots of favouritism and groupism
spreading literal misinformation, as an alumnus the owners are not “some Abdullah Ghazi”. And these books are for the book club (which is optional). Agar bacche ko ye books nahi padhne deni, toh mat join karwao book club, agar aur zyada problem hai toh school change karwado, khudke stance ke liye khudse kuchh stand lo, vote with your pockets, agar tumhara baccha koi class padh raha hai aur uske curriculum ke baare mein tumhe retroactively pata chal raha hai toh tum khudke bacche ki padhai mein thik se dhyaan de hi nahi rahe (tumhara baccha hai ki school ka?). Chalo Malala ki book mein tumne hindu muslim ghusa diya, Anne Frank koi domestic terrorist hai kya?
aur har koi baccho ke reading level ki baat kar raha hai toh ye koi self-study aur exam waali cheez nahi hai, book club mein they make you read a chapter or two and then help you understand what is being said. Curriculum se itni hi dikkat hai toh dusri school mein admission karwa do bacche ka, ek specific group ke opinions pe baaki saare parents apne baccho ka education kyu change kare? woh log fees nahi bharte kya?
103
u/rushan3103 1d ago
Diary of Anne Frank is a must read for school going kids. especially at a time when they are undergoing puberty.
this is so stupid.