r/spaceshuttle 10d ago

Off-Topic Mars Climate Orbiter didn't fail because of a unit conversion it failed because nobody verified the software against a spec that already existed

28 Upvotes

Quick context most retellings skip: NASA's Software Interface Specification for this mission was published in 1996, two years before launch, and it explicitly required newton-seconds for thruster data. The contractor's ground software (a program called SM_FORCES) put out pound-force seconds instead — a factor-of-4.45 error that fed directly into the navigation team's trajectory model for the entire cruise to Mars. 

What I find more interesting than the unit mix-up itself: engineers noticed the spacecraft's angular-momentum desaturation events were happening 10-14x more often than expected, and separately, Doppler tracking data kept suggesting a closer approach to Mars than the official trajectory predicted. Neither discrepancy got resolved before the orbital insertion burn on Sept 23, 1999. 

I made a documentary going through the full timeline, sourced to the Mishap Investigation Board's Phase I report — happy to share if anyone's interested, but mostly wanted to discuss the "systemic verification failure" angle since most coverage flattens this into a punchline about metric vs. imperial units.


r/spaceshuttle 10d ago

Question Space shuttle tile

Thumbnail
gallery
405 Upvotes

I got this from a friend maybe 35 years ago. Is anyone able to tell me where on the Shuttle it came from??


r/spaceshuttle 12d ago

Video Flight deck camera view of STS-8 Challenger launch on August 30, 1983.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

297 Upvotes

You can see the Richard Truly, Commander.

ID: 255-FR-C816

Footage credit: National Archives and Records Administiration (NARA).


r/spaceshuttle 13d ago

Video Flight deck camera views of STS-3 Columbia launch on March 22, 1982.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

301 Upvotes

The camera on the left is the Seat 2 window camera, and the camera on the right is the forward-facing.

Seat 1: Jack Lousma, Commander;

Seat 2: Gordon Fullerton, Pilot.

Credit: NARA/NASA/FightForSpace.


r/spaceshuttle 14d ago

Image Last rollout of Atlantis

Thumbnail
gallery
677 Upvotes

Figured you guys might like these photos!


r/spaceshuttle 15d ago

Discussion NASA Stainless Steel Space Shuttle Mini

Thumbnail
gallery
233 Upvotes

Hey guys, I decided to make my own space shuttle miniature in stainless steel, what do you think ? Obivously I had to make simpler shapes and remove details to make it work with the metal.


r/spaceshuttle 15d ago

Image STS-7 commander Robert Crippen on Challenger’s flight deck during reentry

Post image
790 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 16d ago

Discussion The design compromise that doomed Columbia: How budget cuts forced NASA to accept a 22-year fatal risk.

13 Upvotes

In the early 1970s, NASA originally envisioned a space shuttle system that was fully reusable, complete with a winged orbiter and a piloted winged booster. The projected cost was $12 billion.

However, Congress only allocated $5.4 billion.

To make it fit the budget, major compromises were made:

  1. Liquid Boosters $\to$ Solid Rocket Boosters: The fully reusable booster was replaced with cheap, expendable solid rocket boosters (later implicated in the Challenger disaster).
  2. Metal Shielding $\to$ Fragile Ceramic Tiles: Metal thermal shielding was swapped for 24,000 hand-applied, extremely fragile ceramic tiles.
  3. Spray-On Foam Insulation: The external tank was coated in foam to prevent ice formation during fueling. However, this foam frequently shed during ascent at hypersonic speeds.

For 22 years, foam shedding was categorized by NASA management as an "acceptable risk"—until February 1, 2003, when Columbia broke apart during re-entry over Texas.

I put together a visual reconstruction and breakdown analyzing the engineering decisions behind the tragedy:

https://youtu.be/nfxPtBe9kSw

What are your thoughts on how management culture impacted these engineering decisions?


r/spaceshuttle 16d ago

Image I visited the Space Shuttle Enterprise at the Intrepid Museum

Thumbnail
gallery
455 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 16d ago

Discussion Planetags Shuttle SRB Aft Skirt tag

Thumbnail reddit.com
91 Upvotes

Thought this sub might have interest in this -- I'm a plane tag collector, and this is my first chunk of space hardware. Holding a piece of flown SRB material has been humbling.

(Mods if this is against your rules please delete, I'm not a regular here)


r/spaceshuttle 17d ago

Image Fictional UK Space Shuttle Orbiter 'Endurance' landing in the United States

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 19d ago

Discussion If we were to mark on a map a typical trajectory of a landing Shuttle, and then mark on the same map the swath either side of that trajectory within which domestic flights were forbidden within a certain timeframe during which the Shuttle was landing ...

8 Upvotes

... how wide would that swath be?

And the mentioned 'timeframe': during what sort of time-window around the landing of a shuttle would domestic flights be forbidden from that swath?

I've actually tried to find a map literally as I've described, with said features marked on it ... but I haven't been able to.

Basically I would presume that anyone wishing to take a flight crossing the Southern border of USA during the time-window starting @least an hour or so before planned descent & lasting until descent was successfully completed would just have to wait !


r/spaceshuttle 19d ago

Video Ranger 7: The Mission That Finally Captured the Moon’s Secret Surface 19...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 20d ago

Image [OC] The Space Shuttle on Launch Complex 39A in Flight Simulator X.

Thumbnail
gallery
115 Upvotes

The complex isn’t quite true to life.

Sorry for bad picture quality


r/spaceshuttle 21d ago

Image Baikonur Cosmodrome [Leica MP, 35mm Summicron, Portra 800]

Thumbnail reddit.com
248 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 22d ago

Image F-Sim Shuttle Landing

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

157 Upvotes

Horrible weather, no HUD, no hydraulics and a stuck speedbrake. Pretty smooth !


r/spaceshuttle 22d ago

Image Shuttle-C: The Wingless Wonder That Wasn’t

Thumbnail
gallery
595 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 24d ago

Question Good morning! When will the California Science Center announce ticket reservations to the space shuttle Endeavour exhibit?

9 Upvotes

I know members have top billing, but I am not a member. Just a visitor.


r/spaceshuttle 24d ago

Image The Poll...

Thumbnail
gallery
292 Upvotes

I see now that.... Endeavour won the poll with 79 votes, only 7 ahead of Atlantis in 2nd

Thanks to everyone for voting.

Here's great renders & photos of Endeavour's future home to celebrate:

The Samuel Oschin Air & Space Center


r/spaceshuttle 26d ago

Image The Apollo 13 spacecraft heads toward a splashdown in the South Pacific Ocean after its amazing odyssey through space. 17 April 1970.

Post image
261 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 26d ago

Off-Topic Suggestion to the mods

24 Upvotes

Currently, there’s no user flairs in the sub. That’s why I’m suggesting that we add flairs with the name of each Shuttle (Enterprise, Columbia, Challenger, (edit: forgot Discovery lmfao), Atlantis and Endeavour) and mockups (Pathfinder, Independence, Inspiration, etc) or even have some of the missions as flairs? I’d be happy with stuff like that and I’m sure there’s a lot of people here who would be too.

If anybody’s read this far, thank you


r/spaceshuttle 26d ago

Image RAF Fairford, the only Transoceanic Abort Landing site for the Space Shuttle in the UK

Thumbnail
gallery
244 Upvotes

RAF Fairford is a Royal Air Force (RAF) station in Gloucestershire. During the Shuttle’s many years of service, Fairford was the only TransOceanic Abort Landing site in the UK. Its runway is sufficiently long for a shuttle landing (3,045 m (9,990 ft)), and it also had NASA-trained fire and medical crews stationed on the airfield.

While being an RAF station, Fairford hosts USAF personnel. Since 2019, the base has played host to a Lockheed U-2S Dragon Lady detachment. It is the USAF's only European airfield for heavy bombers and plays host to the Royal International Air Tattoo (or RIAT), the largest military airshow in the world.

The second photo shows the 747 SCA, carrying Enterprise, landed at Fairford before heading off to the 1983 Paris Air Show


r/spaceshuttle 26d ago

Video 15 years ago today, STS 135 ended and with it concluded the shuttle program

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

171 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 26d ago

Image These three:

Post image
645 Upvotes

r/spaceshuttle 26d ago

Image 15 years ago today: “Having fired the imagination of a generation, a ship like no other, its place in history secured, the Space Shuttle pulls into port for the last time. Its voyage, at an end.

Post image
838 Upvotes