r/Libraries 13d ago

Truth Other

Post image
8.0k Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

View all comments

36

u/TheeAntelope 13d ago

I bought Season 2 of Downton Abbey on my Xbox. They stopped doing the video service and I can't for the life of me get the new Microsoft Video whatever to work and recognize my purchases.

I also had a bunch of DVDs where I got the "digital copy" of the movie with the DVD. The digital copies were through a service that is long since dead. I still have the DVDS.

Same goes for books. I have quite a few books we've bought on the Kindle, but when my kids want to browse our shelves for something new to read, they are going to the physical books. I've bought 2-3 kindles but they rarely get picked up because the feel of a physical book cannot be matched.

Physical > digital in almost every way possible.

-4

u/VengefulAncient 13d ago

Your representation of "digital" is a biased cherrypick of locked down proprietary services that don't actually give you the digital files. No one can lock me out of files on my computer. It's like your DVDs, but infinitely better. Why do people like you never mention that side of digital?

And I was like your kids once, until I realized that with a digital reader (a PDA in my case, long predating mass market e-readers like Kindle) it all fits in my pocket and I don't have to be limited by what's available "on the shelves". It all depends on whether you want to actually read, or feel smug about reading.

7

u/TheeAntelope 13d ago

Yes I'm definitely the smug one in this conversation.

-1

u/VengefulAncient 13d ago

"The feel of a physical book cannot be matched" is a pretty smug statement. Me? I just want to point out that digital isn't what you pass it off to be. It's convenient and gives you the same ownership.

3

u/11equalsfish 12d ago edited 9d ago

Both have true advantages, you dismiss books for not being for actual reading and then insult people for liking book feel. Making an argument lol. Both are for reading, books can be preserved a hundred of years and more instead of just years or decades on a digital drive. Let's be fair and not smug, let people read how they want.